Everything you want is everything you see
Mar. 19th, 2010 11:06 amI think with the end of the fourth series, and the departure of the second cast, Skins and I have reached the end of our road. It wasn't that this was a bad series; the running theme of how much the kids were like their parents, even though they'd never admit it, was handled wisely and well, and never hammered home. And last night had some wonderful moments, from Panda's song to Emily's fingers to ending it where and how they did. I just can't face getting invested in another bunch of teens if it's going to be obligatory that one of them dies every time (and maybe my school was unusually safe, but we did not have a 12% mortality rate in the sixth form). It probably doesn't help that whereas last transition we had the then-intriguing Effy to carry us across, presumably this time we've only got Freddie's tiresome sister. I hope it carries on, and I hope it does well, because it's a better and truer portrayal of teenage life than we ever got. But I don't think I'll be there.
Also - there was one moment where I really thought it would turn out that Effy's Cthulhoid visions were true and there really was Something outside the world, trying to get in. That would have been amazing.
Not the sort of show I'd normally watch, but a girl I know was on Snog, Marry, Avoid last night, and what a hateful, homogenising little programme it is. Not being an idiot - unlike the other two victims - she gave as good as she got, but I was still flabbergasted by the presenter's cultish insistence on how wonderful natural was. This on a show which pretends that a computer is doing the makeovers. But then, even before that, you're a hypocrite if you're treating natural as inherently good on television. Or with language.
My problem with Tim Burton's Alice is not just that it's not Tim Burton enough,but that it's not Alice enough. Yes, the latter is made into a plot point - is she the right Alice? Has she lost her muchness? - but this feels like after the fact justification for the need to give her that most hateful of Hollywood must-haves, an Arc. The real Alice didn't have an arc because she didn't need one, she was just a sensible girl surrounded by very silly people, who told them so. And in giving her an arc, Burton has also been obliged to give Wonderland (or here Underland, which is appropriate given it doesn't feel very wonderful) a plot. An utterly generic epic fantasy plot - essentially the film Narnia (which had already been compromised by the inappropriate use of elements of Middle Earth) mixed with a few elements of Oz. I kept expecting a reversal or a twist on this well-worn, misplaced formula. Is it a spoiler to say I didn't get one?
(The trailers were good, though - Matt Smith has a perfect face for 3D)
Also - there was one moment where I really thought it would turn out that Effy's Cthulhoid visions were true and there really was Something outside the world, trying to get in. That would have been amazing.
Not the sort of show I'd normally watch, but a girl I know was on Snog, Marry, Avoid last night, and what a hateful, homogenising little programme it is. Not being an idiot - unlike the other two victims - she gave as good as she got, but I was still flabbergasted by the presenter's cultish insistence on how wonderful natural was. This on a show which pretends that a computer is doing the makeovers. But then, even before that, you're a hypocrite if you're treating natural as inherently good on television. Or with language.
My problem with Tim Burton's Alice is not just that it's not Tim Burton enough,but that it's not Alice enough. Yes, the latter is made into a plot point - is she the right Alice? Has she lost her muchness? - but this feels like after the fact justification for the need to give her that most hateful of Hollywood must-haves, an Arc. The real Alice didn't have an arc because she didn't need one, she was just a sensible girl surrounded by very silly people, who told them so. And in giving her an arc, Burton has also been obliged to give Wonderland (or here Underland, which is appropriate given it doesn't feel very wonderful) a plot. An utterly generic epic fantasy plot - essentially the film Narnia (which had already been compromised by the inappropriate use of elements of Middle Earth) mixed with a few elements of Oz. I kept expecting a reversal or a twist on this well-worn, misplaced formula. Is it a spoiler to say I didn't get one?
(The trailers were good, though - Matt Smith has a perfect face for 3D)